Catering Menu

Mayfair Bagels Catering

Gold Package | Platters | Breakfast | Appetizers & Desserts | Specialty Salads | Hot Food Favorites

There are many caterers to choose from but only one clear choice… Bagels On Main. Whether an intimate social gathering or a large scale corporate or personal event, a Bagels On Main professional catering consultant will guide you through the planning process and ensure an extraordinary affair. Our innovative menu designs, knowledgeable staff and commitment to excellence will allow you the opportunity to be a guest at your own event. So sit back, relax and enjoy the party. You’ve already made the most important choice… Bagels On Main Catering!


Continental Breakfast

Great for corporate meetings or casual get togethers. Assorted fresh Bagels On Main bagels, bialys and flagels, assorted pastry platter, a variety of cream cheeses, butter & jelly. Everything is beautifully presented on elegant catering platters and wicker baskets. Bagels On Main coffee, premium orange juice, complete paper and cutlery service finish off this classic offering.

$10.95 per person (15 guest minimum)


Hot Breakfast Offering

Perfect for brunches, corporate meetings, and seasonal entertaining. Farm fresh scrambled eggs, old fashioned challah french toast or fluffy buttermilk pancakes, bacon, sausage and savory home fries, Bagels On Main coffee, premium orange juice, complete paper and cutlery service, chafing dishes and sterno racks included. A basket of fresh, sliced bagels, bialys, and flagels. Plus, a platter of assorted cream cheeses, butter and jelly to accompany this delicious package.

$15.95 per person (20 guest minimum)


Omelette Station

Have one of our master chefs come to your event and cook to order any style omelette.

$175 (4 hours with Hot Breakfast Offering)


Cream Cheese Platters

Your choice of our assorted cream cheese spreads – including: veggie, nova spread, scallion, sun-dried tomato, olive, garlic and herb, walnut raisin, cinnamon raisin, chocolate chip, and strawberry. (Lite and fat-free cream cheeses available)

Petite Serves 12-15 Guests $59.95 (Choice of 3 / 25 bagels)
Grande Serves 20-25 Guests $84.95 (Choice of 4 / 45 bagels)


Coffee Break

A great mid-afternoon snack – Regular and decaf coffee, cut up fresh fruit in a deco bowl and a delicious platter of our fine pastries and cakes.

$7.49 per person (15 person minimum)


Vegetable Crudite

A beautiful wicker basket filled with an assortment of crispy julienne vegetables, florets of broccoli and cauliflower, ripe cherry tomatoes, and holland pepper spears. Served with a choice of dip. A stunning centerpiece for your buffet table and a must for cocktail parties.

Petite Serves 10-14 Guests $49.95
Grande Serves 20-25 Guests $79.95


Cheese Platter – Sliced or Cubed

A perfect addition to any menu. A stunning presentation of an assortment of fine cheeses. Garnished with grape clusters and fresh strawberries served with flavorful cracker flats.

Petite Serves 12-15 Guests $49.95
Grande Serves 20-25 Guests $79.95


Fresh Fruit

Mouth watering fruit featuring canteloupe, honeydew, watermelon, pineapple, strawberries, red and green grapes, and seasonal specialties.

Petite Serves 15-20 Guests $69.95
Grande Serves 35-40 Guests $110.00


Pastries & Cakes

Delicious old world rugalach, cookies, danish, crumbcake, mini black and whites, and brownies beautifully arranged on platters for any occasion.

$13.95 per lb.


Specialty Salads

Tossed Garden Salad – Iceberg lettuce with cucumber slices, diced red holland peppers, radishes, broccoli florets, julienne of carrot and celery, and ripe cherry tomatoes.

Caesar Salad – Crispy romaine lettuce leaves with bermuda onions and red holland pepper strips – dusted with grated parmesan cheese. Served with a lively garlic parmesan dressing and homemade croutons.

Classic Spinach Salad – Fresh tender leaf lettuce, sliced hard boiled eggs, fresh button mushrooms, diced swiss cheese, bacon bits, sliced bermuda onion.

Greek Salad – Crisp romaine and iceberg leaf lettuce, ripe tomato wedges, bermuda onion, cucumber slices, imported greek olives and chunks of feta cheese.

California Spring Mix – Mesculin lettuce, plum tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, mandarine orange, walnuts, and chunks of feta cheese.

Arugula Mango Salad – Grape tomatoes, red peppers, fresh peeled mangos, cucumbers and craisins over mixed greens.

Portabella Mushroom/Asparagus – Grilled portabella mushrooms, red peppers, grape tomatoes, asparagus, and feta cheese over romaine lettuce.

Petite Serves 10-15 Guests $39.95
Grande Serves 20-25 Guests $59.95

House Salad – Crisp romaine lettuce covered with grilled chicken, goat cheese, mandarin orange, craisins, and walnuts.

Petite Serves 10-15 Guests $44.95
Grande Serves 20-25 Guests $64.95

Choice of 2 Dressings: Fat-free ranch, fat-free italian, fat-free french, lite honey mustard, fat-free raspberry vinaigrette, low-fat honey poppy, french, caesar, russian, thousand island, balsamic vinaigrette, blue cheese, creamy italian, and yogurt dill.


Gourmet Salad Medley

A must for informal get togethers, luncheons, corporate events, bridal and baby showers or any occasion where you crave a Bagels On Main salad platter. Beautiful garnished platters of your choice of 4 salads – one of our gourmet tuna or chicken salads, white fish salad, egg salad, egg white spinach salad, egg onion mushroom salad, or poached salmon salad.

Included in this package are 2 garnished bowls of your choice: pasta primavera, Israeli, tuscany bean, tomato and onion, cucumber, potato, cole slaw, macaroni, red bliss potato, sundried tomato pasta, greek pasta, chick pea, health salad or mediterranean cheese.

A tomato, red bermuda onion, cucumber, and olive platter.

Assorted bagels, bialys and flagels sliced and presented in wicker baskets.

$12.95 per person (12 guest minimum)


Overstuffed Sandwich Buffet

Overstuffed sandwiches of your choice: chicken, classic tuna, low-fat or fat-free veggie tuna, honey mustard tuna, baked salmon salad, whitefish salad, poached salmon salad, classic egg salad, low-fat veggie egg white salad, low-fat egg white spinach salad or Boar’s Head deli meats prepared as you wish on your choice of bagels, wraps, kaiser rolls, egg twist rolls, bialys and flagels.

Your choice of two different salad accompaniments: pasta salad, israeli, tuscany bean, tomato and onion, cucumber, potato, macaroni, cole slaw or tossed garden salad.

Also includes a tray of assorted pickles and olives. (Complete paper and cutlery)

$10.95 per person (15 guest minimum)



Wrap Basket

Choose your favorite Boar’s Head Deli meats and cheeses, or one of our gourmet salads wrapped, garnished and presented in a wicker basket.

Choose 2 of our homemade side salads to include Red Bliss Potato, Cole Slaw, Macaroni, Cucumber & Dill, Pasta Salad, or Tuscany Bean Salad

Assortment of Pickles and Olives

$11.95 per person (10 guest minimum)


Bagels On Main Smoked Fish Medley

An all time favorite perfect for any occasion…

The centerpiece of our platter is a beautiful fillet or stuffed whitefish, surrounded by tempting layers of the finest sable plate, kippered baked salmon and slices of our own master smoked nova and/or belly lox.

A garnished bowl of tender marinated herring fillets in your choice of our classic cream and/or wine sauce.

Your choice of 3 of our homemade cream cheese spreads.

Our beautifully garnished tomato, red bermuda onion, cucumber, and olive platter.

An assortment of your favorite varieties of bagels, bialys and flagels. All sliced to order.

$21.95 per person (12 guest minimum)


Bagels On Main Nosh

The classic bagel and lox platter offering mouth-watering slices of nova and/or belly lox is the centerpeice of this platter which includes all the fixins – fresh assorted bagels & bialys, choice of two of our homemade cream cheeses – sliced tomato and bermuda onion swirl. All beautifully garnished like only Bagels On Main can do!

$13.95 per person (12 guest minimum)


Any Occasion Platter

All beautifully decorated and plattered…

Nova Lox • Tuna & Egg Salad • Plain and Scallion Cream Cheese Sliced Tomato and Onion • Assorted Bagels, Bialys & Flagels

$15.95 per person (10 guest minimum)


Hot Food Favorites

1/2 Tray Full Tray
Honey Balsamic Glazed Salmon n/a $120.00
Blackened Cajun Style Salmon n/a $120.00
Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna n/a MP
Flounder Florentine n/a $95.00
Steamed Vegetables $40.00 $65.00
Rice Pilaf $35.00 $45.00
Grilled Vegetables in a Balsamic Glaze $45.00 $75.00
Lasagna (Vegetable or Spinach) $45.00 $75.00
Fettucini Alfredo $45.00 $75.00
Penne ala Vodka in a Pink Cream Sauce $45.00 $75.00
Pesto Chicken Pasta $45.00 $75.00
Baked Ziti $45.00 $75.00
Pasta Primavera with Fresh Vegetables in a Garlic Shallot Sauce $45.00 $75.00
Eggplant Rollatini $60.00 $80.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $55.00 $75.00
Chicken Francais $55.00 $85.00
Chicken Marsala $55.00 $85.00
Chicken Scarpiello $55.00 $85.00
Chicken Parmigiana $55.00 $85.00
Grilled Chicken (choice of seasonings) $55.00 $85.00
Marinated Grilled Balsamic Chicken $55.00 $85.00
Skirt Steak with Caramelized Onions $75.00 $135.00
Sausage (Hot or Sweet) & Peppers $55.00 $85.00
Roasted Potatoes $35.00 $65.00

Also Includes: Basket of Dinner Rolls, Chafing Dishes and Sterno Racks.


Gold Package

Includes buffet tables with skirts

• A Selection of Mouth Watering Smoked Fish

Nova scotia lox, whitefish fillet, kippered baked salmon, and sable plate Tender marinated herring fillets in cream sauce or wine sauce

• A Choice of Two Gourmet Salads

Classic tuna, honey mustard tuna, lite vegetable tuna, whitefish, baked salmon, poached salmon, classic egg, egg onion mushroom, low-fat vegetable egg white, low-fat spinach egg white

• A Choice of Green Salads

Spinach, california spring mix, greek or caesar

• A Choice of Two Accompaniments

Pasta primavera, greek pasta, sun-dried tomato pasta, tuscany bean salad, mediterranean cheese salad, israeli salad, cucumber salad, tomato and onion salad, potato salad, macaroni salad, cole slaw or health salad

• A Variety of Cream Cheeses

Plain, scallion, and vegetable

• Sliced Tomato & Red Bermuda Onion, Cucumber, and Olive Platter

• Baskets of Assorted Sliced Fruit

Canteloupe, honeydew, watermelon, pineapple, strawberries, and grapes

• Baskets of bagels, bialys and flagels

• Ceremonial challah bread

• Assorted Desserts

Assorted demi danish, cookies, rugalach

• Hot & Cold Beverage Service

Regular and decaf coffee, hot water, assorted tea bags, assorted sodas, juices, Snapple, and water

• Complete Paper Service, Fine Plasticware & Wait Staff

$44.95 per person ($10.00 discount per child. Min. 50 people. Sales tax and gratuity not included.)

Gold package can be customized to meet personal preference.